Secure Coding: CWE-377 – Insecure Temporary Files and How to Avoid Them

In practice, developers often use temporary files to temporarily store data while an application is running. This data must either be processed directly or sent to other parts of the program – and may contain confidential information. However, if these temporary files are not managed securely, they can open vulnerabilities that compromise the confidentiality, integrity, or availability of the application. Common Vulnerability Enumeration CWE-377 describes in detail one such vulnerability related to the insecure creation and management of temporary files.

Advertisement

CWE-377: Insecure temporary file in Java

According to CWE-377, the term “insecure temporary file” refers to a security vulnerability that occurs when a program creates a temporary file in an insecure manner. Attackers could exploit this vulnerability to conduct various malicious activities, including data manipulation, unauthorized data access, or denial of service (DoS). The following problems commonly occur when creating unsafe temporary files:

Predictable File Name: When temporary files have predictable names, attackers can easily guess them and gain access to read or modify the file contents.

Unsafe File Permissions: Incorrect permissions can result in unauthorized users accessing or modifying temporary files.

Race conditions: A time-of-check-to-time-of-use (TOCTOU) race condition can occur when an attacker overtakes an application and creates a file with the same name as the one the application intends to generate. .

In Java, developers often use temporary files for various purposes, such as caching, processing initial data, or storing temporary results. Java provides several ways to create temporary files, including the method File.createTempFile()Which generates a temporary file with a unique name in the default temporary file directory.

Improper use of these APIs may still result in the risks described in CWE-377, as shown in the following code examples:

import java.io.File;
import java.io.IOException;

public class InsecureTempFileExample {
    public static void main(String() args) throws IOException {
        File tempFile = new File("/tmp/tempfile.txt");
        tempFile.createNewFile();
        System.out.println("Temporary file created at: " + tempFile.getAbsolutePath());
    }
}

The code in this example creates a temporary file with a hard-coded file name (tempfile.txt) in the /tmp directory. This approach is insecure for several reasons: The file name is predictable, so an attacker could create a file with the same name before the application, causing the TOCTOU race condition mentioned. The file is created without control over permissions, which may also expose sensitive information.

potential impact

CWE-377 can have serious consequences depending on the use of the temporary file and the sensitivity of the data it contains. Possible effects include:

Information disclosure: If an attacker can guess the name of a temporary file, they may also be able to read its contents if the file is not adequately protected. This then exposes sensitive information like passwords, tokens or personal data.

Data manipulation: An attacker can create or modify a temporary file before it is used by the application, resulting in data corruption or unauthorized changes. Possible consequences of this will be incorrect application behavior or entry of malicious data into the system.

Developer Snapshot: Last Week’s Little News

Denial of service (DoS): By creating temporary files with names used by an application, an attacker can specifically prevent an application from functioning properly and cause a denial of service.

remedial measures

To prevent CWE-377, developers should follow safe coding practices when working with temporary files. Below I show several strategies for safely creating and managing temporary files in Java:

1. Use File.createTempFile() properly

Method File.createTempFile() Generates a unique but random temporary file name, reducing the risk of predictable file names. It also allows developers to specify a directory for the file, although the system’s Temp directory is used by default.

import java.io.File;
import java.io.IOException;

public class SecureTempFileExample {
    public static void main(String() args) throws IOException {
        File tempFile = File.createTempFile("tempfile_", ".tmp");
        tempFile.deleteOnExit(); // Ensures the file is deleted when the JVM exits
        System.out.println("Temporary file created at: " + tempFile.getAbsolutePath());
    }
}

This approach minimizes several risks: The file name is generated randomly, making it difficult for an attacker to predict. The file is automatically deleted when the Java Virtual Machine (JVM) exits, reducing the chance of having outdated files.

2. Make sure file permissions are correct

When creating temporary files, it is important to set proper file permissions to prevent unauthorized access. This can be set in Java using the following methods: setReadable(), setWritable() And setExecutable() Used to control file permissions.

import java.io.File;
import java.io.IOException;

public class SecureTempFileWithPermissionsExample {
    public static void main(String() args) throws IOException {
        File tempFile = File.createTempFile("secure_tempfile_", ".tmp");
        tempFile.setReadable(true, true);
        tempFile.setWritable(true, true);
        tempFile.setExecutable(false);
        tempFile.deleteOnExit();
        
        System.out.println("Temporary file created with secure permissions at: " + tempFile.getAbsolutePath());
    }
}

In this code example, the file is readable and writable only by the owner, reducing the risk of unauthorized access.

3. Avoid hard-coded file names

Using hard-coded file names, as shown in the first insecure example above, is risky because it makes the temporary file name predictable. Always use mechanisms that generate unique, unpredictable file names, such as File.createTempFile(),

4. Handle temporary files in a privileged context

When dealing with sensitive data, it may be beneficial to manage temporary files in a controlled or privileged environment. This makes it possible to create files in a directory with restricted access or use Java AccessControllerWhich can be used to enforce strict security policies for file operations.

advanced ideas

5. Use java.nio.file package

The java.nio.file package introduced in Java 7 provides more robust and flexible mechanisms for file management, including the creation of temporary files. Filesoffers classes createTempFile()Method that can also specify file attributes such as permissions. The code example shows how to set file permissions using the NIO package to enforce fine-grained control over file security attributes:

import java.io.File;
import java.io.IOException;

public class SecureTempFileWithPermissionsExample {
    public static void main(String() args) throws IOException {
        File tempFile = File.createTempFile("secure_tempfile_", ".tmp");
        tempFile.setReadable(true, true);
        tempFile.setWritable(true, true);
        tempFile.setExecutable(false);
        tempFile.deleteOnExit();
        
        System.out.println("Temporary file created with secure permissions at: " + tempFile.getAbsolutePath());
    }
}

6. Consider Using In-Memory Solutions

For some applications, it is possible to avoid creating temporary files altogether by using in-memory storage solutions. ByteArrayOutputStream Use for temporary data. In-memory solutions can replace temporary files in Java applications, resulting in greater efficiency and faster processing. They are particularly beneficial for applications that require data only during runtime. However, there are also disadvantages such as increased storage requirements, data instability, scaling challenges, and security risks that must be carefully considered.

However, the in-memory approach eliminates the risks associated with file system-based temporary storage, but has limited suitability for large data sets or applications with significant memory limitations.

Best Practices When Dealing with CWE-377

To ensure safe handling of temporary files in Java, developers should follow the following best practices:

Prefer safe default settings: Always use methods like File.createTempFile() Or Files.createTempFile()Which provides safe default settings for file creation.

Set file permissions explicitly: Make sure temporary files have the minimum required permissions and avoid giving unnecessary access to other users.

Avoid predictable file names: Never use hard-coded or predictable names for temporary files. Always generate unique file names using secure API.

Use deleteOnExit(), Use whenever possible deleteOnExit() To ensure that temporary files are automatically cleared when the JVM exits.

Limit the size of temporary files: Store temporary files in directories with restricted access and consider creating a dedicated directory for temporary files that require strict security controls.

Handle exceptions properly: When working with temporary files, always handle all exceptions to ensure that the application continues to work safely and stably even if file operations fail.

By following the guidelines and best practices described, Java developers can mitigate the risks associated with CWE-377 and ensure that their applications handle temporary files safely. It is important to use secure APIs, proper file permissions, and careful file management practices to maintain the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of data within Java applications.

Managing temporary files safely is not only a best practice, but an important aspect of developing robust, secure Java applications. Adhering to these principles protects applications from common threats and contributes to a more secure software ecosystem.